« more on msn desktop search | Main | micropatronage »

Feb 18, 2005

Comments

harold

dude. someone has too much free time to think... Isn't Mena keeping you busy?

mattw

Birdsong.

michael

matt, yes! birdsong. exactly.

Allen

Ugh.

Caterina Fake

I don't know. All the electronically created music that I've ever heard has sounded inorganic and unmoving.

I'm thinking of that essay in Hofstadter of the mathematics in the Etudes of Chopin and how the pieces seem surprising and yet at the same time inevitable in retrospect -- and that surprise, that necessariness, that inevitability is where genius lies and is essentially unreproduceable by mechanical means. He talks about this in all of those essays in Metamagical Themas, which, of course I haven't read for years.

Of course, I hate mashups, and probably for the same reason. Individual artists, or bands, develop their own character and language incommensurate with other artists and bands and it is what is idiosyncratic to each is what is vital, and necessary. Mashups seem as if they belong in a category with things like cover bands or Weird Al Yankovic parody songs: amusing and curious, but ultimately lacking the spark of individual genius.

Dick Costolo

"In the future, music will be grown". Whoa. Are you applying to the Kurzweil institute for hyperbole? Here's my application: "In the future, oranges will bark."

Neville

Deep blue beat Kasparov back in '97, mashup alogo-rhythms are just around the corner.

lostgallifreyan

Nice. :) I was googling for stuff to give me an idea of what a mashup was, and this page was the single best, and funniest source of info I found. Keep it up. :)

Mark Simmons

Has this been created yet? Seems like a songbirdpandora product.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment